Emory Hunt stops by the RSP Film Room to present his case for Stanford return specialist and receiver Ty Montgomery. Hunt and I are on opposite ends of the spectrum with Montgomery. We both value his skill as a return man, open field runner, and change-up to the run game.

We differ on his value as a receiver. Hunt is more optimistic about Montgomery’s skill, because of his consistency of technique to attack the ball with his hands and the promise he shows with hard and sudden breaks. I recognize those skills, but I’m not sold on Montgomery’s ball tracking and ability to adjust to inaccurate passes with the consistency that I believe a top receiver would in light of his exposure to a sub par NFL passing prospect like Stanford quarterback Kevin Hogan.

If I were writing the RSP for an NFL team, I’d likely have Montgomery higher on my list due to his versatility in the return game. However, he’s a more specific fit in an offense as a receiver.

The 2015 Rookie Scouting Portfolio is now available.   If you’re in a dynasty league, the combination of the 2015 RSP and the RSP Post-Draft will have you prepared for this year and beyond. Here’s just a sample of what my readers–new and old–are saying about the 2015 RSP.  (Get ready for “Squee!” “Damnit’s” and Jaws Dropping). Remember 10 percent of each sale is donated to Darkness to Light to prevent sexual abuse in communities across the United States. Download the Rookie Scouting Portfolio publication now.