
I will have two teams in this project because I had too much fun just building one. I’m also learning too much from the process to build just one. If you’ve tried building a team, I think you know what I mean. However, I’ll make this team my official roster despite how much I like the other team I’ll share later this month.
The genius of this project is that to feel good about building a team, there has to be a lot of thought and decisions made about factors beyond talent and value before constructing a 53-man roster:
- Football philosophy
- Football strategy
- Team chemistry
Balancing these factors with those of depth, short-term and long-term development of players and scheme, and matching with coaches makes this project a terrific “football architectural puzzle,” to borrow from Jene Bramel (and this won’t be the first time I steal from him in this post).
I think the project has enhanced my empathy towards player-personnel managers. I see why there are few, if any absolutes in the NFL when it comes to the value of positions, prototypes, or schemes. I see the layer of ignorance that persists because of the desire for everyone to generate absolutes that often result in empty truisms and false cliches in an effort to understand the complexity of the game.
Also, I am beginning to understand why a team can give a player more chances to succeed than reporters and fans believe is worthwhile. Or, why talent and fit are often mutually exclusive concepts. There are so many moving parts to consider that it becomes incredibly important to have a vision and develop leadership with the same short, intermediate, and long-range goals. “Winning a championship,” can’t be the only goal.
My Writers Team
The first of my two writers teams is actually the second team I finished, but it’s the one that closely resembles my natural football philosophies. I was surprised it took me so much work to discover what style of football and player resonated with me. I think it has to do with the amount of time I spend watching so many players, but without a specific system in mind. I learn to appreciate a wider cross section of players and can’t cross them off a list.
Offense

Quarterback
Starting Position | Role (optional) | Name | Value | Commentary (Why you picked the player: specific skills and talents you like, potential upside, and/or fit within the system) |
QB2 | Jay Cutler | 14 | This team reflects my desire for an established quarterback capable of elite play. I believe the easiest way to build a winner is to have a quarterback capable of making game-changing, positive plays despite the defense being in the right place at the right time. Jay Cutler isn’t seen as an elite player by many fans and writers, but I believe if you give him quality skill players that match the scheme, he will deliver elite production. Cutler has a great arm, moves well, and he can make accurate throws from difficult platforms. He has repeatedly shown the skill to make plays when the defense has painted him into a corner. My job is to give him at least 2-3 receivers capable of holding up their end of the bargain when Cutler is forced to make these money throws. | |
QB1 | Nate Davis | 0.5 | Skills alone, Davis is more talented than every quarterback under $12 in this exercise. The problem is a lack of maturity. He used his experience with the old-school, defensive-minded Mike Singletary as an excuse for participating in additional negative behaviors that he’s not even in the league. He’s not even playing to the level he should be in the Arena League. The story I heard about his experience in Indianapolis is that former GM Bill Polian brought Davis into camp in 2011 to give him a shot to win the starting role with Manning out for the year. The hope was Davis could be the team’s heir to the throne. Polian reportedly thought Davis was a high first-round talent in terms of ability. Which I know I agree and former NFL scout Russ Lande saw the same thing. Davis arrived out of shape and not in the frame of mind to work and he was booted from the team in less than a week. I’ll take my chances on a $0.5 investment in a guy with the knack and physical skill to be a franchise quarterback if he can mature. Davis and Cutler are similar athletes and arm talents and I think this team can mold him into an effective backup with starter upside in this offense. Great risk-reward investment.My third quarterback at 0.5 is Jonathan Crompton. He’s mobile, flashes some pocket presence, and has enough arm strength to develop into a solid back up with possible upside as a starter. |
Fullback and Tight End Depth Chart | ||||
Starting Position | Role (optional) | Name | Value | Commentary (Why you picked the player: specific skills and talents you like, potential upside, and fit within the system) |
TE1 | H-Back | Vernon Davis | 8 | The trendy tight end in the NFL is Rob Gronkowski, but I’ll put Davis toe-to-toe with Gronkowski every day of the week. To me the only difference between Davis and Gronkowski is Tom Brady and Aaron Hernandez and that actually might make Davis more appealing. Davis can block, make plays deep, run after the catch, and play on or off the line of scrimmage. With A.J. Green outside, and Marshawn Lynch in the backfield, Davis completes a trio of skill players that will force defenses to pick its poison. Like Green, and Lynch, he has also shown the ability to be clutch and the more big-plays-in-big-moments players I have, the more Jay Cutler will shine. |
TE2 | Taylor Thompson | 1.5 | The results of a team’s draft is often seen as a reflection of what that team wants to become in a few years. Taylor Thompson has the potential to develop into an athletic freak at tight end. The former SMU defensive end has excellent hands and the size and athleticism that rivals Rob Gronkowski. If Thompson develops fast, it can give my team the option to use Davis more often as an H-Back or a moveable chess piece much like Aaron Hernandez. This would allow me to run a more multiple offense with two tight end sets and no-huddle tempos that might cause defensive coordinators to file a civil suit for unnecessary pain and suffering. | |
TE3 | Will Yeatman | 0.5 | Yeatman is a big tight end who has shown some skill as a run blocker. He possesses the fluidity of the All-American lacrosse player he was and he can catch the ball. He was the odd man at the end of the Patriots depth chart as an undrafted rookie. He was undrafted due to a DUI issue at Notre Dame that prompted him to leave the program for Maryland. There’s potential for him to become a solid reserve and situational in-line tight end. | |
FB | FB | Shaun Chapas | 0.5 | The former University of Georgia fullback is a good lead blocker. He’s an old-fashioned fullback. Not very fast, but physical. If Tony Fiammetta is too banged up to return to form, Chapas is a sold find. |
FB | FB | Tony Fiammetta | 0.5 | The former Syracuse star has demonstrated elite skill as a run blocker, but a series of injuries have placed his future in question. If he returns to top form, I have a bargain. If not, I’ll settle for Shaun Chapas. |
Tackle Depth Chart | ||||
Starting Position | Role (optional) | Name | Value | Commentary (Why you picked the player: specific skills and talents you like, potential upside, and fit within the system) |
LT1 | Cordy Glenn | 5 | The Bills GM Buddy Nix compares Glenn to a young Marcus McNeill in terms of ability. Nix was in San Diego when the team drafted McNeill, so he should know. If Glenn doesn’t work out as a tackle, I know I can use him as a guard and get solid value from him. However, I’m confident that Glenn has the quickness and potential to develop into a solid left tackle. If Charles Brown plays to his potential, he could earn the left tackle spot and Glenn moves to right tackle. Essentially I think both tackles are “good enough” to develop into competent starters at either edge. | |
RT1 | Charles Brown | 3.5 | Brown is another left tackle prospect and showed signs of life last year with the Saints. I’m thinking right tackle is where I’ll start him and give Cordy Glenn a shot at left tackle. The former second-round pick will compete for the spot on the left side in camp before I ultimately decide where he’ll be. | |
LT1 | Lydon Murtha | 1 | Capable depth. |
Guard Depth Chart | ||||
Starting Position | Role (optional) | Name | Value | Commentary (Why you picked the player: specific skills and talents you like, potential upside, and fit within the system) |
LG1 | Andy Levitre | 9 | Levitre is the reason I feel okay about Glenn or Brown as my left tackle as one of those players grow into the role. He’s an elite pass protector and will do a lot to help that side of the line as Ben Muth mentioned with his RSP team. Levitre has been one of the constants as I made changes elsewhere. Combine Levitre with a player like tight end Vernon Davis if I need to to max protect on the left side and I think I’ll have solid performances that hide the weaknesses of Levitre and either Glenn or Brown when it comes to run or pass. Not that I want to waste Davis’ receiving prowess, but it is always good to have a solid contingency in place if Plan A or B isn’t successful. | |
RG1 | David Decastro | 7 | Like Ben Muth, I’m a big fan of the guard with the potential to be the best prospect at the position in many years. Decastro reminds me of Raider guard Steve Wisniewski, who made eight Pro Bowls and only missed two games in his 13-year career. I know I’m going to be able to run the ball behind behind Decastro whether he’s pulling or zone blocking. His skills will go a long way towards making this offensive line a versatile, balanced unit. | |
LG2 | Trai Essex | 1 | Muth says it well about Essex: big, strong, young, and capable if called upon to play tackle if I’m desperate. He had issues with weight gain after some standout performances as a stand-in starter at right guard and right tackle. He has actually played all five positions for the Steelers and performed well enough to earn praise from Mike Tomlin. He may never be a player I want as a starter, but I know I can get decent efforts from him and rare versatility. Depth is a big factor that separates winning teams from losing teams in a league that prides itself on parody. |
Center Depth Chart | ||||
Starting Position | Role (optional) | Name | Value | Commentary (Why you picked the player: specific skills and talents you like, potential upside, and fit within the system) |
C1 | Doug Legursky | 1 | I won’t be surprised if he’s on a lot more teams. He’s 26, played admirably in the place of Maurkice Pouncey versus Green Bay in the Super Bowl, and he can squat 705 pounds. Strong, technically sound, and also capable of playing guard if one of my starters suffer an injury. He wasn’t given great reviews by the stats analysts studying his play at guard, but he’s played with a bum shoulder that required offseason surgery. He’ll compete for the starting job at center where his strength as a run blocker will be an asset. His versatility is another example of covering all my bases and why building a team takes a lot of thought for contingencies. | |
C2 | Chris Spencer | 1 | Spencer best fit is at center, but he can play guard if called upon. At age 30, he’s still young enough to give me 3-5 years of work at either position although I’m wary of his pass protection if I had to use him at guard, especially with my young tackles. I’d probably move Legursky to guard and use Spencer as my center if it came to that scenario. |
Defensive End and Tackle Depth Chart | ||||
Starting Position | Role (optional) | Name | Value | Commentary (Why you picked the player: specific skills and talents you like, potential upside, and fit within the system) |
DT1 | LDT | Geno Atkins | 9.5 | Ndamukong Suh was my original choice as my defensive tackle, but I decided I was getting too cute trying to move players around the defensive front to gain mismatches. So I opted for Atkins, who is quietly among the best 4-3 defensive tackles in the league and a more disciplined player than Suh. Atkins does a strong job getting pressure up the middle, but he’s a better run defender than many predicted. I hope he can anchor this line for years to come. |
LDE1 | Derrick Morgan | 6 | Morgan was considered the best all-around defensive end in a draft class that included Jason Pierre-Paul, but an ACL tear cost him the first year and a half of his NFL career and set back his development substantially. However, he flashed some skills at the end of 2011 and if he plays to his potential soon, he’s an equally good run defender and pass rusher. Think an aspiring Bruce Smith. With Atkins to contend with in the middle | |
RDE1 | Starting RDE | Brian Robison | 3 | I think Robison is just coming into his own as a player capable of pressuring the quarterback from the right side of the line, but smart enough to make plays in the run game. He’s a better athlete than some realize and I think I have a keeper for a good 3-5 seasons. |
DT2 | NT | Matt Toeaina | 0.5 | Toeania is a good run defender who will be over the A-Gap. |
DT3 | NT | Arthur Jones | 0.5 | Jones is also a good run defender with a strong work ethic. He trains with his brother, MMA figher Jon Jones, and while he’s earning a shot at DE for the Ravens, I like his 315-pound frame and strength as a competitor for the NT role. |
LDE2 | Backup DE | William Hayes | 0.5 | Hayes has the athleticism to become a starter, but his development as a small school player has been slow. I think he can contribute if called upon. |
DT4 | LT | Drake Nevis | 0.5 | Quick, savvy, and a good player at LSU, I like what Nevis did in limited time with the Colts. I’ll let him sit behind Geno Atkins as depth and hope I don’t need him anytime soon. |
![]() Final Special Teams Roster |
||||
Kicker and Punter Depth Chart | ||||
Starters | Name | Value | Commentary (Why did you choose the player for special teams and what Role (optional) will he play?) | |
K1 | Greg Zuerlein | 1.5 | The rookie has long-distance skills as a place kicker and on kickoffs. He’s made two 58-yard field goals and the Rams got rid of starter Josh Brown after drafting him. Considering Jeff Fisher made a good choice with Rob Bironas, I’ll take my chances on Zuerlein. | |
P1 | Ben Graham | 1 | Graham is known for his strong leg. The former Australian Rules Footballer has bounced around, but I’ll give him a shot to get the job done. | |
0 |
Kick Coverage Team | ||
Name | Commentary (Why did you choose the player for special teams and what Role (optional) will he play?) | |
Rod Streater | Good speed and will be my L1 sprinting from the outside. | |
Kyle Wilson | Wilson’s speed and tackling ability will be helpful here. If he beats Brice McCain for the nickel job, McCain will play here as the R1. He’ll also play next to Jeremy Ross on returns, or I’ll flip flip him with Chad Spann and put the running back in that return role alongside Ross. | |
Tahir Whitehead | Speedy linebacker with excellent special teams track record at Temple. He’ll be my aggressive L2. | |
Dwight Lowery | Should have enough speed to be my R2. | |
Bruce Carter | He’ll be my R3 due to his tacklling skill and solid speed. He has a good nose for the football. | |
John Wendling | He’ll be my L3 as a terrific special teams tackler with a nose for the ball. | |
Chad Spann | My L4 who will learn this role but get help on that side from the experienced Wendling. | |
Gerald McGrath | My R4 and a sure tackler. | |
Greg Jones | My L5 who can thump heads, which is what you need as a head forcer or tracker. | |
Kirk Morrison | Another good hitter who will be my R5. |
Jeremy Ross | Return specialist. Streater out on returns, but replaces Ross on kick team. Might alternate with Kyle Wilson to keep fresh. |
Punt Coverage Team | ||
Name | Commentary (Why did you choose the player for special teams and what Role (optional) will he play?) | |
Chris Spencer | Will try at long snapper. Off the field with Kirk Morrison replacing him for return team. | |
Lydon Murtha | Guard on punt team/off field on return team with Gerald McGrath replacing him. | |
Trai Essex | Guard on punt coverage team/ off the field on return team with Greg Jones replacing him. | |
Dwight Lowery | Wide receiver on coverage team and will play on return side. | |
Bruce Carter | Slot back on coverage team and will also play on return side. | |
John Wendling | Slot back on coverage team and will also play on return side. | |
Chad Spann | Personal protector on punt team. | |
Tahir Whitehead | Wide receiver on coverage team and will play on return side. | |
Rod Streater | Wide receiver on coverage team and will play on return side. | |
Kyle Wilson | Wide receiver on coverage team and will play on return side. | |
Jeremy Ross | Return specialist |
4 responses to “Matt Waldman’s RSP Writers Team”
Awesome team, Matt. Great depth, and your offense is especially scary. It looks like the biggest weaknesses would be unproven commodities and safety and pass-rusher, but with the guys you have at CB and LB you should be able to scheme around that effectively if Morgan/Searcy/Nelson don’t pan out. I’ve got a decent idea of what you’ll be running on both sides of the ball but I can’t wait to read your Q&A.
OpenOffice has been shitting itself whenever I try to open the spreadsheet with updated player values; might try to track down some new (free) software this weekend, cuz I’m itching to reconstruct my own team.
Really looking forward to seeing what you do Troy. I’ll be happy to post what you construct.
I was fully expecting Davis and Pearman on your team. Guess I’m batting .500. 🙂 Should have known you’d roster Spann as well.
Lot of youth going on here. I guess that shouldn’t be too surprising either, given the site on which we’re participating in this.
It’s interesting to see who the “duplicates” on the teams so far has been. McCain/Essex/Legs have shown up on most so far, IIRC. Most have either rostered Levitre, or bemoaned not being able to as well.
[…] Waldman’s 2012 RSP Writers Team […]